Join the Largest Private Label and Contract Manufacturing Group on LinkedIn

How to Choose a Private Label Supplement Manufacturer: 18 Key Factors

by | Jun 26, 2023

Choosing the right private label supplement manufacturer is vital for your business’s success. With numerous options available, it can be overwhelming. This guide will provide essential criteria to help you make an informed decision. Whether expanding your product line or starting fresh, this guide will steer you toward the ideal manufacturing partner for growth and success.

Before proceeding further, here is an exciting fact:

The supplements industry has experienced significant expansion in recent years, gaining immense popularity among consumers and occupying a substantial share of advertising. It is noteworthy that despite the lack of FDA regulation, the industry thrives. Zippia’s comprehensive research reveals the following statistics:

  • Approximately 77% of Americans incorporate at least one supplement into their routine.
  • As of 2022, the U.S. vitamin and supplement manufacturing industry boasts a value of $35.6 billion.
  • Projections indicate that the global supplements industry will witness a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 6.9% from 2021 to 2026.

According to these statistics, the demand for supplements and their supply from manufacturers is increasing. And because buying supplements is a matter of trust, private-label manufacturers are always preferred.

So let’s discuss how you would decide whether a private label supplement manufacturer is trustworthy.

18 Key Factors to Consider in Choosing a Private Label Supplement Manufacturer

So, the journey starts here with the major question: What should be considered when choosing a private label supplement manufacturer? It includes the desired manufacturer’s quality, reliability, and expertise in producing vitamins that could make a significant difference in decision-making.

Therefore, by measuring these factors specifically related to vitamins, you could ensure that the collaboration with the desired and right manufacturer aligns with your business goals and can deliver the highest quality standards.

1) Quality and Manufacturing Standards

It is factual that maintaining impeccable quality and adhering to stringent manufacturing standards are essential for business success and customer satisfaction in the private label supplement industry. Therefore, how can we go about doing that?

Here are various factors to ensure that products meet high-quality and safety standards:

  • Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) certification demonstrates a manufacturer’s commitment to upholding industry-leading guidelines, ensuring the safety and efficacy of their products.
  • Stringent quality control measures and testing protocols throughout the manufacturing process guarantee consistent product quality.
  • While compliance with regulatory requirements such as those set by the FDA and NSF ensures adherence to safety and labeling standards.

Point to be noted: Additionally, since white-label supplements are sold under the brand name, it is crucial to ensure that the manufacturer maintains high product quality and transparency standards.

2) Product Range and Specializations

Evaluating product range and specialization helps ensure that the private label supplement manufacturer can meet your needs, maintain product quality, and provide value to your target market. Well, what’s the approach to get that done?

Here are some key points to keep in mind:

  • Assess the manufacturer’s expertise in supplement production, ensuring they have the knowledge and expertise to satisfy your specific requirements.
  • Search for a manufacturer that provides various supplement products, such as multivitamins, omega-3 fatty acids, protein powders, calcium, and vitamin D.
  • Additionally, consider their customization options for private-label supplements, enabling you to differentiate your brand.

Furthermore, it is also important to pen down that assessing the manufacturer’s product range and customization options for private label vitamins is also important to meet customer demand and create brand differentiation.

3) Manufacturing Capacity and Scalability

Specializing in a particular product range, such as nutrition supplements, indicates that the manufacturer has the experience and expertise to produce high-quality nutritional supplements.

Were you clued in with the above-mentioned fact? But what steps should be taken to attain that?

Don’t forget these important factors:

  • Assess the manufacturer’s production capabilities, including their ability to handle large orders and accommodate fluctuations in demand, specifically for nutrition supplements.
  • Consider their facilities and equipment to ensure efficient manufacturing processes for nutrition products such as protein bars.
  • Review their timely order fulfillment track record to ensure they have a history of meeting delivery deadlines for nutrition supplements.

Look for a manufacturer that can produce diverse dietary supplements, such as capsules, weight loss supplements, tablets, protein supplements like powders, soft gels, herbal supplements, skin care supplements, and gummies. Ensure they meet your current and future production needs while maintaining product quality. Including vitamins E, D3, A, C, and B12 in your product line ensures that your dietary or pet supplements meet health-conscious consumers’ demands.

  • L-Glutamine supplements can help minimize muscle breakdown and enhance protein metabolism.
  • Buffered C Crystals aid in collagen production and durability, forming the foundational framework for bone, skin, ligaments, tendons, blood vessels, and other bodily tissues.
  • The B-Complex Gummies assist in promoting cell growth, aiding digestion, supporting healthy brain and eye function, and facilitating proper nerve function.

4) Ingredient Sourcing and Transparency

When choosing a private label supplement manufacturer, assessing their ingredient sourcing and transparency practices are essential to assuring the quality and integrity of your products. Hence, what is the recommended course of action to achieve that?

Remember these essential aspects:

  • Regarding ingredient sourcing and transparency, it’s essential to ensure that the manufacturer provides detailed information about the origins and quality of all components used in their product, including CBD supplements, such as CBD oil, capsules, edibles, topicals, and tinctures.
  • Transparency in ingredient sourcing and traceability should be prioritized, with the manufacturer providing information on the origin and quality of the ingredients used.
  • Ensure the manufacturer complies with sustainability and ethical sourcing practices. Look for evidence of sustainable ingredient sourcing, fair trade certifications, transparent supply chains, environmental initiatives, and social impact projects. This ensures your private-label supplements align with ethical and sustainable values.

5) Product Development and Formulation Support

Product development and formulation support from a private label supplement manufacturer is crucial because it brings expertise, customization, and quality to your supplements. It ensures optimal formulations, regulatory compliance, and differentiation from competitors.

Thus, let’s take note of these crucial considerations:

  • Look for a manufacturer with in-house formulation expertise, ensuring they carry the knowledge and skills to create high-quality supplements.
  • Assess their ability to assist in product development and customization and access to research and development resources to stay at the forepart of industry trends.
  • Consider whether they support label design and packaging options, helping you create a visually appealing, market-ready product.

6) Reputation and References

Selecting a private label supplement manufacturer requires careful consideration of their reputation and references to establish a dependable and trustworthy collaboration.

How to do that?

Consequently, keep these vital points in your thoughts:

  • Conduct thorough research on the manufacturer’s reputation in the industry, considering factors such as their track record, longevity, and customer satisfaction.
  • Read customer reviews and testimonials to gauge the relevant experiences of others who have worked with the manufacturer.

7) Pricing and Terms

When considering a private label supplement manufacturer, evaluating their pricing and terms is essential to ensure a mutually beneficial partnership. Hence, what is the recommended course of action to achieve that?

Don’t overlook these significant highlights:

  • Obtain detailed pricing information and seek transparency regarding costs, including manufacturing, packaging, and additional fees.
  • Evaluate the pricing competitiveness in the market to be sure that you are acquiring a fair value for your investment.

8) Communication and Customer Support

Embarking on the journey to find the perfect private-label supplement manufacturer demands a discerning eye for assessing production capabilities, unwavering product quality, seamless communication, and unparalleled customer support. Effective communication and reliable customer support are essential for maintaining a successful partnership and ensuring a seamless manufacturing process.

Check out how you can understand a private label supplement manufacturer’s communication and customer support:

  • Availability and responsiveness of customer support: Being accessible and responsive to customer inquiries and issues showcases a commitment to customer satisfaction, fosters trust, and enhances the overall customer experience.
  • Precise and efficient communication channels: Providing multiple communication channels and ensuring clear and concise interactions helps customers feel heard, understood, and valued, improving customer satisfaction and loyalty.
  • Proactive updates on manufacturing progress and order status: Keeping customers informed of the progress of their orders through proactive updates demonstrates transparency, builds trust, and mitigates potential concerns or frustrations.

9) Turnaround Time and Lead Times

Turnaround time is when the manufacturer completes the production and delivery of your specific product order. Lead time, on the other hand, refers to the total time required from placing the order to receive the finished products.

For turnaround and lead time, what are the various components that have to be noted?

These noteworthy factors are worth remembering:

  • Evaluating a manufacturer’s estimated turnaround time and lead times for your product order is crucial to ensure they can meet your desired production timelines and avoid delays in getting your products to market.
  • This involves assessing their ability to meet your desired timeline, especially if you have specific launch dates or promotional campaigns in mind.

10) Minimum Order Quantities (MOQs)

Minimum Order Quantities (MOQs) refer to the minimum number of units or products the manufacturer requires you to order in a single batch. MOQs can vary significantly between manufacturers and could fundamentally impact business operations and budgets. So, in what manner can that be accomplished?

Don’t miss out on these essential reminders:

  • When selecting a manufacturer, it is vital to evaluate their MOQs to ensure they align with your business needs and budget.
  • You need to determine if the MOQs are feasible for your initial order and if they can accommodate potential growth in the future.

11) Scalability and Growth Potential

Scalability and growth potential refer to the manufacturer’s ability to accommodate and support the expansion of your business in terms of production capacity and product offerings. Thus, what’s the recommended way to go about it?

Keep these important insights on your radar:

  • Assessing a manufacturer’s ability to scale production as your business grows is decisive to ensure they can meet increasing demand and maintain consistent product supply, supporting your business’s expansion and customer satisfaction.
  • Inquire about their capacity to handle increased order volumes and whether they can accommodate adding new product lines, including multivitamins, calcium and vitamin D, vitamin C, and herbal supplements.

12) Sampling and Testing

Sampling and testing emerge as indispensable pillars when handpicking a private label supplement manufacturer. These pivotal processes unravel the mysteries of product quality, tantalizing taste, unrivaled efficacy, and unwavering compliance.

In light of this, remember these standout points:

  • To safeguard your brand’s reputation and prioritize customer well-being, it is crucial to inquire about the manufacturer’s sampling and testing procedures. This ensures the quality, safety, and compliance of your private label supplements, including omega-3 fatty acids, protein powders, probiotics, vitamin B complex, iron, and magnesium.
  • Additionally, confirm that they conduct rigorous testing for raw materials plus finished products to ensure consistency and compliance with quality standards.

13) Supply Chain Management

Supply chain management plays a crucial role in the success of private label supplement businesses. Choosing the right manufacturer directly impacts product quality, timely delivery, and customer satisfaction. Quality manufacturing ensures safe and effective supplements, timely delivery avoids stockouts and missed opportunities, and customer satisfaction builds brand reputation and fosters growth.

Don’t lose sight of these pivotal factors:

  • Inquiring about a manufacturer’s sampling and testing procedures is essential to ensure that the private label supplements meet the required quality standards, comply with regulations, & provide safe and effective products to your customers.
  • Ensure they provide samples to assess the product’s quality, taste, and efficacy.

Read our latest blog: Key Considerations When Choosing a Private Label Manufacturer

14) Product Documentation and Certifications

When choosing private label supplement manufacturers, You must prioritize product documentation and certifications. These crucial elements demonstrate top-notch quality, safety, and compliance. Hence, what is the recommended course of action to achieve that?

Keep these standout elements for better understanding:

  • This factor is essential to ensure compliance with regulations, demonstrate product quality, and establish customer trust.
  • Ensure they can supply certificates of analysis (COAs), product specifications, allergen statements, and any relevant certifications specific to the supplement industry.

15) Research and Development (R&D) Capabilities

The presence of strong Research and Development (R&D) capabilities is a critical factor to consider when choosing a private label supplement manufacturer. It refers to the manufacturer’s ability to innovate, develop, formulate new products, and stay abreast of the latest research and industry trends. So, in what manner can that be accomplished?

Stay mindful of these critical touchpoints:

  • The factor ensures the ability to support the development and realization of your vision, resulting in differentiated and market-leading private-label supplements.
  • Determine if they have a dedicated R&D team and access to the latest research and trends in the supplement industry.

Note: Verifying regulatory compliance ensures legal adherence and consumer safety for private label vitamins.

16) Intellectual Property Protection

Protecting your Intellectual Property is important for safeguarding your innovative ideas and preventing unauthorized use or infringement. It involves safeguarding your proprietary information and trade secrets and ensuring the manufacturer’s commitment to confidentiality. Thus, what’s the recommended way to go about it?

Remember these standout insights as you proceed:

  • The factor ensures confidentiality and safeguards your proprietary information throughout manufacturing.
  • NDAs serve as legal agreements to protect your proprietary information and trade secrets.

17) Customer Support and After-Sales Service

Prioritizing customer support and after-sales service defines the credibility of a manufacturer. It also encompasses the manufacturer’s ability to provide assistance, address inquiries, handle complaints, and support customers after the sale. But what steps should be taken to attain that?

Don’t skip over these noteworthy factors:

  • Monitor their pace at assistance, how they solve your queries, and overall satisfaction before the deal.
  • Use the use-cases or storytelling to understand how they handle inquiries, complaints, returns from customers, or any other difficult situations.

18) Sustainability and Environmental Considerations

It helps promote ethical practices, reduce environmental impact, and meet the growing demand for eco-friendly products. It involves assessing the manufacturer’s commitment to sustainable practices and their efforts to minimize their environmental impact. Well, what’s the approach to get that done?

Keep these essential aspects front and center as you navigate:

  • When evaluating a manufacturer, assess their commitment to sustainability.
  • Inquire about their waste management processes, energy efficiency initiatives, and use of eco-friendly packaging materials.

Making an Informed Decision for Your Top Private Label Supplement Manufacturers

Making a well-informed decision in choosing a private label supplement manufacturer ensures a partnership with a provider who can meet your specific needs. It guarantees compatibility, quality assurance, regulatory compliance, and expertise in your target market.

You can select a reliable manufacturer to deliver high-quality products by considering the above factors. This ultimately contributes to the success of your brand, establishes credibility, and satisfies your customers’ expectations, leading to long-term growth and profitability.

Choosing a reputable private label supplement manufacturer significantly influences product quality, safety, and brand reputation. Thorough research is essential to ensure compliance, customer satisfaction, and long-term success.

FindMyManufacturer simplifies the buying process by helping you locate the vendors you need in one convenient platform. Whether you’re looking for specific products, components, or services, FindMyManufacturer provides personalized assistance or a custom supplement manufacturer based on procurement expertise to help you find exactly what you’re looking for.

Get your personalized quote now by connecting with reputable manufacturers who deliver quality products.


How can private-label supplement manufacturers benefit my business?

Private-label supplement manufacturers offer expertise, resources, and infrastructure to produce high-quality supplements under your brand. This allows you to enter the market quickly, save on production costs, and focus on marketing and growing your business.

How can I ensure the quality and safety of the supplements produced by a private-label manufacturer?

To ensure quality and safety, choose a private label manufacturer that follows Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) and complies with relevant regulatory bodies. Look for manufacturers with third-party certifications such as NSF, FDA registration, or ISO 9001. Request product testing documentation and ask for references or reviews from other clients.

What certifications or qualifications should I look for in a private-label supplement manufacturer?

Look for certifications such as NSF, FDA registration, or ISO 9001, as they demonstrate adherence to quality standards. Additionally, certifications like GMP and HACCP are crucial for ensuring manufacturing practices that prioritize safety and compliance.

What is the typical lead time for manufacturing private-label supplements?

The lead time can vary depending on factors such as order size, complexity of the formulation, and the manufacturer’s production capacity. Generally, lead times range from a few weeks to a few months. It is best to discuss specific lead time requirements with potential manufacturers.

Can a private-label supplement manufacturer help with product formulation and packaging design?

Private label manufacturers offer services to help with product formulation and packaging design. They often have in-house experts who can assist in customizing formulas to meet your specific needs and offer packaging options to align with your brand image. It’s important to inquire about these services when selecting a manufacturer.